Find my creations on facebook http://www.facebook.com/#!/tinabartondesigns

I understand your feeling about the quilt but I'd still double-check with her about the top of the quilt getting more abuse. She might really appreciate you pointing out the fact. Folks who don't sew or understand the construction process don't always think things through very well. The reason I say this is from working with customers who were often grateful when I'd point out something that might work better for them. If after it's brought to her attention and she still says she'd rather have it made with the stronger fabric on the bottom so be it. Then go with her choice. Just my opinion, take or leave it.
Rebecca in Baarn, Netherlands by way of Orange County, CA.
I agree with Rebecca...but you might also point out the fact that she is going to be spending big $$$$ and that you cannot guarantee your work if she allows her dogs to lie on with her. I believe I would have her sign something saying she understands and will not hold you accountable for the condition of the quilt once she allows her precious babies to sleep on it. Here is something we nurses say "COVER YOUR BUTT, COVER YOUR BUTT"!
LIVE well, LAUGH often, LOVE much
Hugs, Pat
Take photos and keep sample swatches of the fabrics too.
I'd find some twill. That is pretty durable and fairly lightweight. Check near the denim & bottom-weights section of the fabric store for it. It comes in neutrals and some brights.
I don't know if they still sell brush-popper anymore, but it is lighter weight than denim and is designed to be made into long-sleeve shirts to protect your arms while riding through or working with bushes that would like to chew up your arms. That would also work.
I am with the others, I'd be more concerned about the wear the top is gonna take!
Good luck!
I have a policy of not making quilts as gifts for people who have dogs on the bed, commision would be with a disclaimer that normal wear and tear does NOT include Dog claws. If they want to spend the money anyway, thats their decision eh?
That's how I look at it. Her dogs, her bed, her money, her quilt. As long as you get it in writing that once she takes posession of it you are not responsible for wear and tear.
What about high thread count cotton? I found some at Hancock's, VERY limited colors but very wide and I think it's more durable. Less space in between fibers for claws to catch hold.
I made a nightgown out of it, it is so much softer and much more comfortable than the other one I made with the regular cotton.
I liked it so much I got some high thread count sheets to cut up because sheets have a better color selection.
Cathryn