I can't respond to your poll, because I do a little of each, depending on my mood, the quilt, and if I want a scrappy or more planned look. I tend to go toward scrappy, and don't make the pieces all one length. But I do agree with what Sandy said, since your quilt is very "organized" looking, a more organized approach to the binding would look better. I like the idea of using the colors in your quilt in same size pieces for the binding, that way you get the randomness of color, but the precision of size. It looks soooo good, I'm not sure if I could sew small squares carefully enough to make a quilt like that. I'm working on that aspect of my piecing.